[TONYMOLY] Vital Vita12 Fresh Sun Stick SPF 50+ PA++++ 22g vs Extra Care Non-Greasy Sunscreen SPF 50

Shared ingredients· none here

Product facts and full ingredient lists side by side

on 2+ labelsonly on this labelnot on this labelIngredient	Recommended Tonymoly [TONYMOLY] Vital Vita12 Fresh Sun Stick SPF 50+ PA++++ 22g $16.80 $19.50 at Ballagrio ↗Save	Paula's Choice Extra Care Non-Greasy Sunscreen SPF 50 $26.00 Save
Basics
Type & size	Sunscreen · size not on the record	Sunscreen · size not on the record
Brand origindiffers	Korean	American
Offers
Where to buydiffers	$19.50 · Ballagrio	Not recorded
Formula
Key activesdiffers	squalane, niacinamide, sodium ascorbyl phosphate, panthenol, retinyl palmitate	sodium ascorbyl phosphate, retinyl palmitate, titanium dioxide
Free ofdiffers	Not recorded	fragrance-free, sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free
Heads-updiffers	pregnancy caution · photosensitizing · fragrance allergensPore data not yet reviewed	pregnancy caution · photosensitizing · fungal-acne triggerPore data not yet reviewed
Fit & community
Rating	No reviews yet	No reviews yet
Best for	Not recorded	Not recorded
Data quality
Label coveragediffers	Partially captured — 47 of 65 label entries matched, some checks not run	Fully parsed · 25 ingredients
Key actives · 4
pro-vitamin b5	yes	no
squalane	yes	no
titanium dioxide Pregnancy: generally fine	no	yes
vitamin b3	yes	no
Rest of the labels · 48
1,2-hexanediol	yes	no
adenosine	yes	no
aloe vera	no	yes
bentonite	no	yes
benzophenone-3 Pregnancy: caution	no	yes
benzotriazolyl dodecyl p-cresol	yes	no
bht	yes	no
biotin	yes	no
butyl methoxydibenzoylmethane	no	yes
calcium pantothenate	yes	no
caprylyl glycol	yes	no
chlorphenesin	no	yes
cinnamyl alcohol	yes	no
citronellol	yes	no
cyanocobalamin	yes	no
dipropylene glycol	yes	no
disodium edta	no	yes
ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate Pregnancy: caution	yes	no
ethylhexyl palmitate Possible fungal-acne trigger	yes	no
ethylhexylglycerin	no	yes
folic acid	yes	no
fragrance	yes	no
geraniol	yes	no
glycerin	yes	no
glyceryl arachidonate	yes	no
hydrogenated lecithin	yes	no
kaolin	no	yes
lecithin	yes	no
limonene	yes	no
linalool	yes	no
maltodextrin	yes	no
methyl glucose sesquistearate Possible fungal-acne trigger	no	yes
microcrystalline wax	yes	no
octyldodecanol	yes	no
phenoxyethanol	no	yes
picea abies wood extract	no	yes
poly c10-30 alkyl acrylate	yes	no
polyglyceryl-10 oleate Possible fungal-acne trigger	yes	no
portulaca oleracea extract	yes	no
pyridoxine	yes	no
pyridoxine hcl	yes	no
sodium hydroxide	no	yes
sodium polyacrylate	no	yes
sodium starch octenylsuccinate	yes	no
synthetic wax	yes	no
thiamine hcl	yes	no
vinyl dimethicone	yes	no
water	no	yes

Tonymoly's label is only partially captured — rows may grow as parsing completes.

Rows come from parsed labels and live offers. Where a label isn’t fully captured, we say so instead of guessing.

The bottom line

Both lines come from the parsed labels and the prices on this page — neither product is the reference, and neither is called the better one.