Petal Fresh, Clarifying Body Butter, Mandarin & Mango, 8 oz (237 ml) vs Palmer's, Shea Butter Formula® with Vitamin E, Daily Body Lotion, Raw Shea, 8.5 fl oz (250 ml)

Petal Fresh, Clarifying Body Butter, Mandarin & Mango, 8 oz (237 ml) and Palmer's, Shea Butter Formula® with Vitamin E, Daily Body Lotion, Raw Shea, 8.5 fl oz (250 ml) share 10 parsed ingredients. Differences highlighted below.

Show all ingredients

Shared 10Petal Fresh, Clarifying Body Butter, Mandarin & Mango, 8 oz (237 ml) only 20Palmer's, Shea Butter Formula® with Vitamin E, Daily Body Lotion, Raw Shea, 8.5 fl oz (250 ml) only 13

2 of 6

Permalink for this comparison →

Shared formula

23%

Ingredients in every formula: 10in both formulas
Key actives unique to one formula: 2unique actives
Ingredient rows compared: 43rows compared

From the parsed labels — rows on every label over all compared rows.

The formulas, row by row

43 ingredients across 2 labels

Differences only(33 of 43 rows)

Shared ingredients· none here

Product facts and full ingredient lists side by side
on 2+ labelsonly on this labelnot on this labelIngredient	Recommended Petal Fresh Petal Fresh, Clarifying Body Butter, Mandarin & Mango, 8 oz (237 ml) $7.70	Palmer's Palmer's, Shea Butter Formula® with Vitamin E, Daily Body Lotion, Raw Shea, 8.5 fl oz (250 ml) $5.17
Basics
Type & size	Body lotion · size not on the record	Body lotion · size not on the record
Brand origindiffers	Not recorded	American
Offers
Where to buy	Not recorded	Not recorded
Availability	in stock	in stock
Formula
Key activesdiffers	argania spinosa kernel oil, panthenol	Not recorded
Free of	sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free, silicone-free	sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free, silicone-free
Heads-up	fragrance allergens · fungal-acne trigger · high pore-rating flag	fragrance allergens · fungal-acne trigger · high pore-rating flag
Fit & community
Rating	No reviews yet	No reviews yet
Best for	Not recorded	Not recorded
Data quality
Label coveragediffers	Fully parsed · 30 ingredients	Fully parsed · 23 ingredients
Key actives · 2
argan oil	yes	no
pro-vitamin b5	yes	no
Rest of the labels · 31
arnica montana flower extract	yes	no
benzyl alcohol	no	yes
benzyl benzoate	no	yes
benzyl salicylate	no	yes
borago officinalis seed oil	yes	no
butyrospermum parkii butter extract	yes	no
carbomer	no	yes
carthamus tinctorius seed oil	yes	no
citrus limon fruit extract	yes	no
coconut oil	yes	no
dehydroacetic acid	yes	no
glycerin	yes	no
glyceryl stearate se Possible fungal-acne trigger	yes	no
helianthus annuus seed oil	yes	no
hexyl cinnamal	no	yes
limnanthes alba seed oil	yes	no
limonene	yes	no
mangifera indica fruit extract	yes	no
melaleuca alternifolia leaf oil	yes	no
mentha piperita leaf extract	yes	no
olive oil	yes	no
palmitic acid Fungal-acne trigger	no	yes
peg-40 stearate Possible fungal-acne trigger	no	yes
phenoxyethanol	no	yes
propylene glycol	no	yes
prunus amygdalus dulcis oil	yes	no
sclerocarya birrea seed oil	no	yes
simmondsia chinensis seed oil	yes	no
sodium metabisulfite	no	yes
sodium sulfite	no	yes
tetrasodium edta	no	yes

Rows come from parsed labels and live offers. Where a label isn’t fully captured, we say so instead of guessing.

The bottom line

Choose Petal Fresh if you want Argan oil in the formula.

Choose Palmer's if you want a comparable formula for $2.53 less.

Both lines come from the parsed labels and the prices on this page — neither product is the reference, and neither is called the better one.

This is not medical advice.

Focus on an effect

All ingredients

Brighten & fade dark spots Clear breakouts Smooth fine lines Hydrate & plump

Calm redness Refine texture Repair & strengthen Protect from sun

People also compare

More suggestions →

Suggested from shared ingredients on the parsed labels — each pair opens as its own comparison.