Benton Heartleaf 80 Skin Toner Pad 70pads vs P.CALM, Barrier Cycle Toner, 6.76 fl oz (200 ml)

Shared ingredients· none here

Product facts and full ingredient lists side by side

on 2+ labelsonly on this labelnot on this labelIngredient	Benton Benton Heartleaf 80 Skin Toner Pad 70pads $42.40 $42.40 at Kbeautymakeup ↗Save	Recommended P.calm P.CALM, Barrier Cycle Toner, 6.76 fl oz (200 ml) $20.65 Save
Basics
Type & size	Toner · size not on the record	Toner · size not on the record
Brand origindiffers	Korean	Not recorded
Offers
Where to buydiffers	$42.40 · Kbeautymakeup	Not recorded
Availabilitydiffers	Not recorded	in stock
Formula
Key activesdiffers	allantoin, panthenol, mandelic acid, sodium hyaluronate	niacinamide, panthenol, allantoin, sodium hyaluronate, centella asiatica extract
Free of	fragrance-free, sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free, silicone-free	fragrance-free, sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free, silicone-free
Heads-updiffers	pregnancy caution · photosensitizingPore data not yet reviewed	pregnancy cautionPore data not yet reviewed
Fit & community
Rating	No reviews yet	No reviews yet
Best for	Not recorded	Not recorded
Data quality
Label coveragediffers	Fully parsed · 25 ingredients	Fully parsed · 30 ingredients
Key actives · 3
cica	no	yes
mandelic acid Pregnancy: generally fine	yes	no
vitamin b3	no	yes
Rest of the labels · 30
acacia seyal gum extract	no	yes
adenosine	no	yes
amorphophallus konjac root extract	no	yes
arginine	yes	no
bambusa vulgaris extract	no	yes
betaine salicylate Pregnancy: caution	yes	no
capryloyl salicylic acid Pregnancy: caution	yes	no
carica papaya fruit extract	no	yes
chamaecyparis obtusa leaf extract	no	yes
cynanchum atratum extract	yes	no
dextrin	yes	no
dipotassium glycyrrhizate	yes	no
disodium edta	no	yes
gluconolactone	yes	no
hamamelis virginiana water	no	yes
houttuynia cordata extract	yes	no
lactobacillus ferment	no	yes
lavandula angustifolia extract	yes	no
oryza sativa bran extract	no	yes
pinus densiflora leaf extract	no	yes
plantago asiatica extract	no	yes
propanediol	no	yes
rosmarinus officinalis extract	yes	no
sodium chloride	yes	no
sodium guaiazulene sulfonate	no	yes
thuja orientalis extract Pregnancy: caution	no	yes
thymus vulgaris extract	yes	no
water	yes	no
water	no	yes
xanthan gum	no	yes

Rows come from parsed labels and live offers. Where a label isn’t fully captured, we say so instead of guessing.

The bottom line

Both lines come from the parsed labels and the prices on this page — neither product is the reference, and neither is called the better one.