BANOBAGI Alpha Radiance Melaclear Cream (Tube Type) vs Goodal, Black Carrot, Vita-A Retinol Cream, 1.69 fl oz (50 ml)

BANOBAGI Alpha Radiance Melaclear Cream (Tube Type) and Goodal, Black Carrot, Vita-A Retinol Cream, 1.69 fl oz (50 ml) share 20 parsed ingredients. Differences highlighted below.

Show all ingredients

Shared 20BANOBAGI Alpha Radiance Melaclear Cream (Tube Type) only 11Goodal, Black Carrot, Vita-A Retinol Cream, 1.69 fl oz (50 ml) only 33

2 of 6

Permalink for this comparison →

Shared formula

31%

Ingredients in every formula: 20in both formulas
Key actives unique to one formula: 3unique actives
Ingredient rows compared: 64rows compared

From the parsed labels — rows on every label over all compared rows.

The formulas, row by row

64 ingredients across 2 labels

Differences only(44 of 64 rows)

Shared ingredients· none here

Product facts and full ingredient lists side by side
on 2+ labelsonly on this labelnot on this labelIngredient	Banobagi BANOBAGI Alpha Radiance Melaclear Cream (Tube Type) $39.52	Recommended Goodal Goodal, Black Carrot, Vita-A Retinol Cream, 1.69 fl oz (50 ml) $30.60
Basics
Type & size	Moisturizer · size not on the record	Moisturizer · size not on the record
Brand origindiffers	Not recorded	Korean
Offers
Where to buy	Not recorded	Not recorded
Availabilitydiffers	Not recorded	in stock
Formula
Key activesdiffers	niacinamide, alpha-arbutin, panthenol, centella asiatica extract, sodium hyaluronate	niacinamide, centella asiatica extract, sodium hyaluronate, panthenol, retinol, hyaluronic acid
Free ofdiffers	fragrance-free, sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free, silicone-free	fragrance-free, sulfate-free, alcohol-free, paraben-free
Heads-updiffers	pregnancy caution · fungal-acne triggerPore data not yet reviewed	pregnancy caution · photosensitizing · fungal-acne triggerPore data not yet reviewed
Fit & community
Rating	No reviews yet	No reviews yet
Best for	Not recorded	Not recorded
Data quality
Label coveragediffers	Fully parsed · 31 ingredients	Fully parsed · 53 ingredients
Key actives · 3
alpha-arbutin Pregnancy: caution	yes	no
hyaluronic acid Pregnancy: generally fine	no	yes
vitamin a	no	yes
Rest of the labels · 41
a silicone	no	yes
adenosine	no	yes
arginine	no	yes
asiatic acid	yes	no
asiaticoside	yes	no
beta-carotene	no	yes
beta-glucan	no	yes
betaine	no	yes
bisabolol	yes	no
canola oil	no	yes
cetearyl alcohol	no	yes
cetearyl olivate	no	yes
decyl glucoside	yes	no
diisostearyl malate	yes	no
dimethiconol	no	yes
dimethylsilanol hyaluronate Pregnancy: generally fine	no	yes
ectoin	no	yes
hippophae rhamnoides fruit extract	yes	no
hydrogenated lecithin	no	yes
hydroxyacetophenone	no	yes
jojoba esters	no	yes
madecassic acid	yes	no
madecassoside	yes	no
methylpropanediol	no	yes
pentaerythrityl tetra-di-t-butyl hydroxyhydrocinnamate	no	yes
pentylene glycol	yes	no
phellodendron amurense bark extract	no	yes
phenylpropanol	no	yes
phloretin	no	yes
polyglyceryl-10 stearate Possible fungal-acne trigger	no	yes
polyvinyl alcohol	no	yes
portulaca oleracea extract	no	yes
sodium hyaluronate dimethylsilanol Pregnancy: generally fine	no	yes
sorbitan isostearate Possible fungal-acne trigger	yes	no
sorbitan olivate Possible fungal-acne trigger	no	yes
tetrahydropiperine	no	yes
tocopheryl acetate	no	yes
trisiloxane	no	yes
vinyl dimethicone	no	yes
vitamin e	no	yes
xanthan gum	no	yes

Rows come from parsed labels and live offers. Where a label isn’t fully captured, we say so instead of guessing.

The bottom line

Choose Banobagi if you want Alpha-Arbutin in the formula.

Choose Goodal if you want Vitamin A in the formula.

Both lines come from the parsed labels and the prices on this page — neither product is the reference, and neither is called the better one.

This is not medical advice.

Focus on an effect

All ingredients

Brighten & fade dark spots Clear breakouts Smooth fine lines Hydrate & plump

Calm redness Refine texture Repair & strengthen Protect from sun

People also compare

More suggestions →

Suggested from shared ingredients on the parsed labels — each pair opens as its own comparison.